Compare
Recurly vs Stripe Billing
Both are the billing system of record, not a metrics layer. Stripe Billing suits teams already on Stripe; Recurly is a dedicated subscription platform.
Side by side
| Recurly | Stripe Billing | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vendor | Recurly | Stripe | ||||||||||||||
| Pricing model | Subscription | Usage-based | ||||||||||||||
| Free tier | No | No | ||||||||||||||
| Deployment | Cloud | Cloud | ||||||||||||||
| Open source | No | No | ||||||||||||||
| Best for | Mid-market and enterprise subscription businesses that want billing, churn prevention and revenue reporting in one system. | Companies already processing payments through Stripe who want billing and subscription reporting in the same platform. | ||||||||||||||
| Pricing | Starter plan is a flat fee plus a percentage of billing volume; higher tiers are priced as a percentage of billing volume with a minimum, billed annually.
Prices read from the vendor's own page on September 21, 2026. Vendors change prices; check the source before you budget. | Pay-as-you-go pricing is a percentage of billing volume; discounted flat monthly rates are available for predictable volume under an annual contract, plus Stripe's standard payment-processing fees.
Prices read from the vendor's own page on September 21, 2026. Vendors change prices; check the source before you budget. | ||||||||||||||
| Features |
|
|
Verdict
Recurly and Stripe Billing both process the recurring charge itself rather than reading someone else's billing export, so their MRR and churn figures come from the same ledger used to invoice the customer. That is the real choice here: not which dashboard looks better, but which platform you want handling the charge.
Stripe Billing's advantage is proximity: if payment processing already runs through Stripe, subscriptions, invoicing and usage-based billing live in the same account, with no second vendor relationship or reconciliation between payments and subscription state. Recurly is a dedicated subscription-billing platform built around retaining revenue once a charge fails — its dunning and payment-retry logic, plus optional revenue-recognition and lifecycle-messaging add-ons, are purpose-built for reducing involuntary churn rather than being a byproduct of a broader payments product. Recurly also supports more payment gateways beyond its own, which matters if you process payments somewhere other than Stripe.
Choose Recurly if
- You want a subscription platform purpose-built around retaining revenue, with dunning and recovery logic as a first-class feature rather than an add-on.
- Your payment processing isn't on Stripe, or you want billing independent of your processor.
- You run mid-market or enterprise subscription volume and want add-on modules for revenue recognition (RevRec) or lifecycle messaging (Engage).
Choose Stripe Billing if
- Payment processing already runs through Stripe and you want subscriptions in the same account rather than a second vendor.
- You want pricing that scales as a flat percentage of billing volume, with discounted flat rates available at predictable volume.
- Your billing needs are usage-based or hybrid and you want that handled natively alongside standard recurring plans.
The honest caveat
Neither of these is a lightweight decision: both are the system that sends the invoice, so switching later means migrating live subscriptions, not just re-pointing a dashboard. If you're only trying to see MRR and churn without changing how you bill, look at a reader tool like Baremetrics or ChartMogul first — see how to choose a SaaS metrics tool.
Last reviewed September 22, 2026